Being a Brewer fan 10 years ago was a bit like being a sports fan before ESPN came along. The amount of information you could consume, and amount of discourse relating to your passion was limited. Sports fans in the 1970s depended on the newspaper and 8 minute clips at the end of the local news for your information. Discourse with other fans? Sure you could talk with any friends and family members but that was probably about it.
Like sports fans in the 1970s, the Brewer fans of 10 years ago were in a similar predicament. To get your Brewer news, you had the local TV news and newspaper- and that was only if you were lucky enough to live in the Milwaukee area. I used to be excited when I visited family in the area because I would get to read the expanded Brewer sections in the Milwaukee Journal. Even the Internet revolution was slow to start with Brewer fans. Lame, infrequently updated, and numerous Brewer fan sites popped up- none of which came close to filling the giant void that existed.
Enter Brewerfan.net
The site entered as a serious place for fans to talk not only the Brewers- but baseball in general. The creators had a goal in mind of what they wanted the site to be, what kind of site they did not want to be, and what type of discourse they wanted on their message boards. The site boasts incredible information on all Brewer baseball from the June Draft to the Minor Leagues to the Big Show. Today the site is a great database for all Brewer news. The message boards however.....
Suck.
How is this? Why is it mind numbingly boring to read? Why is there a 85 post thread on Jason Kendal batting 9th? A 466 post thread on Roger Clemens? Why do I learn 5 times as much by scanning through
Rightfieldbleachers.com every morning than by looking at the first few postings on Brewerfan?
I've read Brewerfan for a few years but never posted. I would guess that 90% of people who dislike a message board dislike it because a) their postings get deleted b) people rip on their postings. Neither has ever happened to me (Don't get me wrong- I'm sure I would get ripped on if I did post). I judge good message boards on amount of new information, ease of reading and the content of the postings.
Rules, rules and more rules.
There is a rules of conduct. Tag directions and Guildlines. Questions and Suggestion tabs. Designated Threads. A discipline policy. A lineup thread. A resource FAQ.
There is a Brewerfan.net President. Director of Research. Director of Amateur Scouting. Fan Forum Director. Dungeon Master.
I understand where Brewerfan is coming from. I don't want 5 threads each with a different proposed lineup. I don't want 2 threads on why Turnbow sucks. BUT. I also hate reading though 5 posts about what forum a thread belongs in. Or 3 posts on what rules a post broke. Or anything to do with Tags and guildlines. Take it easy fellas. This limits postings big time. On the front page right now there is a post about something Dusty Baker said 3 days ago. I know its Spring Training and their isn't much news - but I have a ton of Brewer related thoughts going through my head at all times, there are tons of new blog updates and articles every day on JSOnline, and the Brewer message board seems to be doing what it can to discourage Brewer discourse.
My suggestion. Take it easy guys. I know there are some dumbshit Brewer fans out there. And those fans have computers. I get it. I have sat in $10 seats during a bobblehead giveaway and behind many obese families wearing goofy foam Prince "crowns" (Remember that game K.P.?). I've seen the worst of the worst. I know you don't want 85 threads on the same subject. I get that. But relax. Let people post. Encourage it. If the post sucks let it fall to the bottom of the page. If the post is repetitive - delete it. Trust me. People would rather you simply deleted a repetitive thread rather than spend 3 posts debating it. Encourage people to ignore stupid posts rather than debate what forum they belong in. I don't believe Yuku is charging you by the number of posts.
Thanks Brewerfan for all you've done. You've done for Brewer fans what ESPN has done for sports fans. But just like ESPN needs to evaluate and improve on what they're doing (there are approximately 6,552,335 blogs letting them know this)...so do you.